News

Court upholds 30-year jail term for man who killed wife, two children

The justices ruled that the sentence imposed on Wilson Monday was neither illegal nor manifestly excessive, considering that he killed three members of his family and concealed their bodies in a pit latrine for about four months.

Court upholds 30-year jail term for man who killed wife, two children
By: Barbra Kabahumuza, Journalist @New Vision

_________________

The Court of Appeal has upheld a 30-year prison sentence imposed on a man convicted of murdering his wife and two children, dismissing his appeal against the punishment on grounds that it was harsh and excessive.

The justices ruled that the sentence imposed on Wilson Monday was neither illegal nor manifestly excessive, considering that he killed three members of his family and concealed their bodies in a pit latrine for about four months.

Monday had been convicted on three counts of murder and sentenced to 30 years' imprisonment for killing his wife, Scola Kanyunyuzi, and 22 years on each of the other two counts for murdering their children, Israel Monday and Eunice Kabarokole.

The sentences were ordered to run concurrently.

In a judgment delivered on November 20, 2026, a panel comprising Deputy Chief Justice Moses Kazibwe Kawumi, Irene Mulyagonja and Jesse Byaruhanga Rugyema dismissed the appeal and upheld the 30-year sentence on the first count.

The court noted that Monday had challenged both his conviction and sentence in his original appeal. However, it struck out the first ground, which accused the trial judge of failing to properly evaluate the evidence, describing it as too general and contrary to the requirements of the Court of Appeal Rules.

Consequently, the appeal proceeded on the sentence alone, with Monday arguing that the 30-year jail term was manifestly harsh and excessive.

According to the court record, Monday and his wife developed irreconcilable differences in November 2015. Shortly afterwards, Kanyunyuzi and their two children went missing.

In March 2016, Kanyunyuzi's father reported their disappearance to police after searching for them without success.

Monday was arrested but denied knowledge of their whereabouts. Community members later joined the search, leading to the recovery of the three bodies from his pit latrine.

Following a court-ordered exhumation, the Government Analytical Laboratory confirmed the identities of the deceased and established that they had died from severe bleeding caused by deep cut wounds.

Through his lawyer, Samuel Muhumuza, Monday argued that the trial judge had failed to ensure consistency in sentencing.

His lawyer cited previous court decisions in which murder sentences had been reduced to 20 years' imprisonment and asked the appellate court to substitute the sentences of 30 and 22 years with 18 years on each count.

However, chief state attorney Adubango, representing the prosecution, opposed the appeal and asked the court to dismiss it.

She argued that the trial judge had considered the aggravating and mitigating circumstances before passing sentence.

The prosecution told the court that the murders were premeditated and brutal, adding that Monday had concealed the bodies, misled relatives about the family's whereabouts and later brought another woman to live in the matrimonial home.

She also argued that the appeal challenged the sentence on the first count only, yet Monday was seeking reductions on all three counts.

In its consideration, the appellate court observed that sentencing is primarily within the discretion of the trial judge and that an appellate court can only interfere where a sentence is illegal, based on a wrong principle, or manifestly harsh or excessive.

The justices noted that the 2013 Constitution Sentencing Guidelines for Courts of Judicature prescribe a starting point of 35 years' imprisonment for murder, with a sentencing range of 30 years to death.

The trial judge had initially arrived at a sentence of 33 years' imprisonment before deducting the three years Monday had spent on remand, leaving him with 30 years.

The court further observed that the trial judge had considered the mitigating factors presented by the defence, including Monday's status as a first-time offender.

The justices said the cases cited by the defence were distinguishable because they involved the murder of one person, while Monday had killed his wife and two children.

They also cited previous decisions, including Munyaneza Spiriano versus Uganda, in which a 31-year sentence for murdering a wife was upheld, and Musa Kambale versus Uganda, where a life sentence for murdering a five-year-old boy was substituted with 30 years' imprisonment.

The court concluded that the trial judge had exercised his discretion judicially and found no basis to interfere with the sentence.

Monday will therefore continue serving the 30-year sentence alongside the concurrent 22-year sentences imposed on each of the other two counts.

Help us improve! We're always striving to create great content. Share your thoughts on this article and rate it below.

Tags:
Justice
Court of Appeal
Wilson Monday