News

Court quashes Auditor General’s report on Kaddunabbi

The judge declared that the use of the report without demonstrating genuine and open consideration of Kaddunabbi’s representations was procedurally improper and inconsistent with Article 42 of the Constitution.

Former Insurance Regulatory Authority (IRA) Chief Executive Officer Ibrahim Lubega Kaddunabbi. (File photo)
By: Farooq Kasule, Journalist @New Vision

 ________________ 

The High Court in Kampala has quashed the Auditor General’s report on former Insurance Regulatory Authority (IRA) Chief Executive Officer Ibrahim Lubega Kaddunabbi, barring its use as a basis for his prosecution over procedural flaws.

In a ruling delivered on November 9, 2026, Justice Isaac Bonny Teko of the Civil Division of the High Court in Kampala said the report dated May 19, 2026, shall not be used as a report to Parliament or as a basis to institute prosecution against Kaddunabbi.

He cited procedural flaws and deficits in its creation as well as the caveat and limits the Auditor General himself placed on its scope.

“Given the procedural flaws and deficits identified in the creation of the report,  as well as the specific caveat and limitation imposed by the Auditor General on the scope of the report, the report shall not be used as a report to Parliament or as a basis to institute prosecution against the applicant,” Justice Teko ruled.

The judge declared that the use of the report without demonstrating genuine and open consideration of Kaddunabbi’s representations was procedurally improper and inconsistent with Article 42 of the Constitution.

He said the finance ministry permanent secretary, Dr Ramathan Ggoobi, illegally usurped the finance minister’s power when he took on a responsibility that belonged to the minister who was still in office, and thus his actions were illegal.  

The ruling followed an application by Kaddunabbi challenging the report’s legality. He argued that Ggoobi, who is also the Secretary to the Treasury, lacked the authority to request for the probe, while the Auditor General improperly entered an employment dispute.

Kaddunabbi also argued that the investigation and the later use of the report denied him procedural fairness.

However, the judge declined to determine whether the allegations about Kaddunabbi’s financial management were true or whether his contract ought to have been renewed, saying these were not questions for resolution through judicial review.

In an affidavit, Ggoobi said the IRA board was divided over renewing Kaddunabbi’s contract because of concerns about his financial management and implementation of board policies, including remuneration, leave payments, travel expenditure and recruitment.

On March 19, this year, Ggoobi requested for an independent assessment by the Auditor General, which was completed on May 15, and discussed by the board before it took a decision on renewal of his contract.

However, Justice Teko observed that by the time the report was issued, the board had already decided not to renew his contract, and, therefore, the report was not the basis for that decision.

The Judge also found that the report was purely for the purpose of supporting or rejecting the IRA board’s decision not to recommend Kaddunabbi to the minister for re-appointment.

Kaddunabbi’s contract expired on May 31 this year. On May 28, he had expressed interest in being recommended for renewal, but the board declined.

Court documents show that the board declined by majority vote for several reasons, including an alleged unapproved adjustment of his salary made without board approval or the finance minister’s consent, which cost sh337m by June 30, 2025.

Other reasons cited were the unauthorised recruitment of six excess staff between February and March 2024, which allegedly inflicted an unbudgeted burden of sh647m on the authority.

In his affidavit, former IRA board chairperson Dr Isaac Nabeta Nkote said the rejection also relied on the Auditor General’s report, which he said unearthed several administrative and financial flaws under Kaddunabbi’s stewardship.

The matter concerning his re-appointment is pending before High Court Judge Joyce Kavuma. Dr Protazio Sande has since been appointed the acting IRA chief executive officer.

Help us improve! We're always striving to create great content. Share your thoughts on this article and rate it below.

Tags:
Auditor General
Ibrahim Lubega Kaddunabbi
Court