News

Court bars Jet Tumwebaze from representing self in Mawogola North petition

Justice Bernard Namanya ruled that Tumwebaze cannot act as an advocate in proceedings in which he is also a principal witness, having sworn affidavits containing the allegations on which his petition is based.

Tumwebaze also challenges the academic verification documents, alleging that Uganda National Examinations Board verification letters referred to another person and that the documents presented did not belong to Kaguta. (Credit: Barbra Kabahumuaza)
By: Barbra Kabahumuza, Journalist @New Vision


MASAKA - The High Court in Masaka has barred Mawogola North parliamentary election petitioner Jet John Ndamagi Tumwebaze from representing himself as an advocate in the petition challenging the election of  Godfrey Aine Kaguta.

Justice Bernard Namanya ruled that Tumwebaze cannot act as an advocate in proceedings in which he is also a principal witness, having sworn affidavits containing the allegations on which his petition is based.

The ruling, delivered on November 18, 2026, followed an application by Kaguta seeking to disqualify Tumwebaze from appearing as his own advocate in Election Petition No. 10 of 2026.

Kaguta argued that Tumwebaze was occupying three roles in the same case: petitioner, principal witness and advocate conducting the proceedings.

Through his lawyers, Kaguta relied on Regulation 9 of the Advocates (Professional Conduct) Regulations, which prohibits an advocate from appearing in court in a matter in which he or she has reason to believe that they will be required to give evidence, either orally or by affidavit.I

He argued that Tumwebaze had sworn the principal affidavit supporting the petition and another affidavit in rejoinder, making him a key witness whose evidence would be subjected to cross-examination.

Kaguta further contended that allowing Tumwebaze to conduct the proceedings as an advocate while also testifying would prejudice his right to a fair hearing and interfere with the orderly conduct of the trial.

Tumwebaze, however, maintained that he had sworn the affidavits as the petitioner and not as a witness for another person.

MP Godfrey Aine Kaguta (R) argued that Tumwebaze was occupying three roles in the same case: petitioner, principal witness and advocate conducting the proceedings. (Credit: Barbra Kabahumuza)

MP Godfrey Aine Kaguta (R) argued that Tumwebaze was occupying three roles in the same case: petitioner, principal witness and advocate conducting the proceedings. (Credit: Barbra Kabahumuza)



He also relied on Order 3 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, arguing that it allows a party to appear in person and that his professional qualification did not take away that right.

He further submitted that Kaguta had not demonstrated any specific prejudice arising from his decision to conduct his own case.

In his ruling, Namanya considered Regulation 9 of the Advocates (Professional Conduct) Regulations and the Supreme Court decision in Uganda Development Bank versus MS Kasirye, Byaruhanga and Company Advocates.

In that case, the Supreme Court held that an advocate required to give evidence in a matter cannot continue appearing as counsel in the same proceedings.

The Supreme Court explained that an advocate in such circumstances must relinquish one of the two roles: either remain a witness and cease acting as counsel, or continue as an advocate and abandon the evidence.

Namanya said Regulation 9 does not distinguish between an advocate representing another person and one appearing in his or her own case.

The judge held that Tumwebaze was a principal witness in the petition and could not simultaneously conduct the proceedings from the bar as an advocate.

He consequently allowed Kaguta's application and declared that Tumwebaze was prohibited from appearing as an advocate in Election Petition No. 10 of 2026.

The judge issued an order formally disqualifying Tumwebaze from representing himself as an advocate in the matter

However, the court directed that the costs of the application would abide by the outcome of the main election petition.

Jet John Ndamagi Tumwebaze (Pictured) filed the election petition challenging Kaguta's victory as Mawogola North Member of Parliament in Sembabule District following the January 15, 2026, parliamentary elections. (Credit: Barbra Kabahumuza)

Jet John Ndamagi Tumwebaze (Pictured) filed the election petition challenging Kaguta's victory as Mawogola North Member of Parliament in Sembabule District following the January 15, 2026, parliamentary elections. (Credit: Barbra Kabahumuza)



Background

Tumwebaze filed the election petition challenging Kaguta's victory as Mawogola North Member of Parliament in Sembabule District following the January 15, 2026, parliamentary elections.

According to Electoral Commission results, Kaguta was declared the winner with 15,923 votes against Tumwebaze's 6,955.

Other candidates included Francis Kigongo Masanga, who polled 112 votes; Angellah Kigonya Namyalo, 274; Moses Lyazi, 74; Idi Semata, 294; and John Ezra Twiine, 42

In his petition, Tumwebaze seeks to have Kaguta's election nullified, alleging that he did not possess the academic qualifications required to contest for Parliament.

He claims that Kaguta lacked the Primary Leaving Examination, Uganda Certificate of Education and Uganda Advanced Certificate of Education qualifications.

Tumwebaze also challenges the academic verification documents, alleging that Uganda National Examinations Board verification letters referred to another person and that the documents presented did not belong to Kaguta.

The petition further raises allegations of military deployment, violence, intimidation, ballot stuffing, multiple voting, voting by unregistered, deceased or absent persons, inconsistencies in declaration forms and bribery.I

Kaguta has denied the allegations, maintaining that he possessed the required academic qualifications and was validly elected.

In his response, Kaguta states that he completed advanced-level education and that UNEB verified his Uganda Certificate of Education and Uganda Advanced Certificate of Education qualifications.

He also maintains that differences in his names were addressed through a deed poll

Kaguta has disputed the allegations of violence, arrests, bribery, ballot stuffing and military involvement, asking the court to dismiss the petition with costs.

The Electoral Commission and Sembabule district returning officer Gracious Aryaija are also respondents in the petition.

The ruling on Tumwebaze's representation follows an earlier court session in which both Kaguta and Tumwebaze rejected Justice Namanya's proposal to consider mediation before proceeding with the hearing of the election petition.

During the proceedings, Kaguta said he wanted the petition heard, while Tumwebaze also opposed mediation, insisting that the allegations raised in his petition required determination by the court.

The parties subsequently proceeded with preparations for the hearing, with the court setting November 24, 26 and 27, 2026, as hearing dates.

Kaguta is represented by Anthony Bazira, Paul Kuteesa and Robert Bautu, while the Electoral Commission and the returning officer are represented by Kandeebe Ntambirweki, Eddy Nsansa, Haruna Ssewaya and Eric Sabiiti.

Help us improve! We're always striving to create great content. Share your thoughts on this article and rate it below.

Tags:
Justice Bernard Namanya
Court
Jet John Ndamagi Tumwebaze
Godfrey Aine Kaguta