News

Court awards former Igara Tea Factory employee sh745,000 over dismissal

Ayebazibwe had sued the tea factory seeking about sh88.4m, arguing that his dismissal was wrongful, unfair and unlawful.

The company suspended Ayebazibwe on January 31, 2018, on half pay for two weeks and directed him to appear before its disciplinary committee on February 14, 2018. (File photo)
By: Barbra Kabahumuza, Journalist @New Vision

 ________________ 

The Industrial Court has awarded a former Igara Growers Tea Factory employee sh745,000 after finding that although his dismissal was justified over missing fertiliser, the company failed to explain his rights during the disciplinary hearing.

Justice Anthony Wabwire Musana, sitting with panellists Adrine Namara, Susan Nabirye and Michael Matovu, ruled that the factory was entitled to summarily dismiss Delmas Ayebazibwe after he admitted signing blank fertiliser delivery notes.

However, the court found that the company had violated the procedural requirements of a fair disciplinary hearing by failing to inform Ayebazibwe in writing of his right to call witnesses, cross-examine those testifying against him and be accompanied by a representative.

In an award delivered on November 17, 2026, the court ordered Igara Growers Tea Factory Limited to pay Ayebazibwe four weeks' net wages amounting to sh745,000 under Section 66(4) of the Employment Act.

The court dismissed the rest of his claim, including demands for general damages, severance allowance, notice pay and unremitted National Social Security Fund contributions.

Ayebazibwe had sued the tea factory seeking about sh88.4m, arguing that his dismissal was wrongful, unfair and unlawful.

He had been employed by the company in 2007 as an estate herdsman before being promoted to field extension officer in 2013.

The dispute arose following an internal audit conducted in November 2017, which reportedly established that 878.80 bags of NPK fertiliser issued for distribution to farmers had not been accounted for.

The company suspended Ayebazibwe on January 31, 2018, on half pay for two weeks and directed him to appear before its disciplinary committee on February 14, 2018.

During the proceedings, Ayebazibwe admitted signing three blank delivery notes at the request of a storekeeper.

In his written defence, he explained that the storekeeper had asked him to sign the documents, claiming they related to about 150 bags of fertiliser.

He further stated that he later discovered additional forged entries in his movement-in-voucher records and delivery notes.

The factory subsequently dismissed him on February 26, 2018, following the disciplinary committee's recommendation.

Ayebazibwe argued that he was not accorded a fair hearing because he was only asked to write a statement without being given an opportunity to question witnesses or call people who could explain the missing fertiliser.

He also contended that the storekeeper, whom he accused of involvement in the irregularities, was not called before the disciplinary committee.

The factory, through its lawyer Dan Wegulo, maintained that Ayebazibwe had been informed of the allegations, invited to a disciplinary hearing and given an opportunity to defend himself.

The company further argued that his admission of signing blank delivery notes demonstrated misconduct that justified his dismissal.

In its analysis, the court considered whether the dismissal was procedurally and substantively fair.

On procedural fairness, the judges found that the company had properly informed Ayebazibwe of the allegations, given him 14 days to prepare his defence and specified the 878.80 bags of fertiliser he had allegedly failed to account for.

However, the court faulted the suspension letter for merely directing him to attend a fair hearing without explaining his rights during the proceedings.

The judges observed that an employee facing disciplinary action must be informed of the right to respond to allegations, be accompanied by a representative, cross-examine witnesses and call witnesses in their defence.

The court consequently found that the disciplinary process was procedurally unfair.

On substantive fairness, however, the judges held that Ayebazibwe's own admission of signing blank delivery notes amounted to a fundamental breach of his employment contract.

The court observed that the employment relationship depended on mutual trust, fidelity and good faith, adding that his admitted conduct undermined the confidence necessary for continued employment.

The judges also rejected the argument that the dismissal was unlawful because criminal proceedings instituted against him had been dismissed for want of prosecution.

They explained that internal disciplinary proceedings and criminal prosecutions serve different purposes and operate independently, meaning an employer does not have to wait for the conclusion of a criminal case before taking disciplinary action.

The court further dismissed the factory's preliminary objection challenging the competence of the claim over the failure to attach the Labour Officer's formal referral letter.

It held that the omission was a curable procedural irregularity because the existence of the labour dispute referral from Bushenyi had been established during the proceedings.

The court therefore awarded Ayebazibwe sh745,000 for the failure to explain his disciplinary hearing rights but rejected his other claims.

Ayebazibwe was represented by Lawrence Tumwesigye of Lawrence Tumwesigye & Co. Advocates, while the factory was represented by Dan Wegulo of Wegulo & Wandera Advocates.

Help us improve! We're always striving to create great content. Share your thoughts on this article and rate it below.

Tags:
Igara Tea Factory
Court