National
Court dismisses report on Justice Choudry probe
Publish Date: Jun 19, 2014
Court dismisses report on Justice Choudry probe
  • mail
  • img
newvision

By Hillary Nsambu

The Court of Appeal has quashed a report in which the Judicial Service Commission had recommended the investigation and removal of Justice Anup Singh Choudry from the High Court Bench as a judge.

 
The court ruled on Wednesday that the JSC had not given Choudry a chance to defend himself against accusations by the Uganda Law Society and: therefore his rights had been violated. The ULS accused Choudry of incompetency and asked the JSC to recommend for his removal.
 
“In our considered view that after the stage of finding a prima fasciae case, the JSC ceases to have authority to proceed with the matter by way of trial, if the person concerned is a judge. At that stage it must consider whether or not to make a recommendation to the President to constitute a tribunal to consider removal of a judge.
 
Before it makes any determination, however, the JSC is obliged to investigate the complaint by itself or by anyone else authorized by it.

Otherwise it would have no basis on which to submit or not its recommendations,” the court said in the ruling read by Justice Solomy Balungi Bbosa.  
 
“It is our decision, therefore, that the JSC erred when it considered the complaint against the appellant without observing his right to appear and present his case at the meeting of the Commission. This omission vitiated the proceedings against the appellant. The JSC also erred when it failed to communicate the decision it reached to the appellant, contrary to the rules of natural justice,” the court ruled.                        
Justice Remmy Kasule headed the coram. The other members were Justices Richard Buteera and Solomy Balungi Bbosa, who read the judgment.
 
The court agreed with Jimmy Muyanja, representing Choudry that the appellant stood to suffer substantial loss and irreparable damages, which could not be atoned for damages if an injuction stopping the JSC from implementing or pursuing the advice to the appointing authority to appoint a tribunal to consider his removal from office as a judge before he had been accorded a chance to defend himself.
 
Choudry’s appeal followed a judgment in which High Court Judge Vincent Zehurikize refused his application for a judicial review after the JSC had recommended his removal from office ad a sitting judge.
 
Muyanja had also submitted that the decision of the JSC to advise the President to set up a tribunal to inquire into the conduct of his client (appellant) was never communicated to him.
 
The court ruled that although the Uganda Law Society, like any other person, had the liberty to file a complaint with the JSC against the judge, the JSC should under the law of fair hearing have accorded him a hearing to hear his side of the story.
 
The court also ruled that before the JSC undertakes the exercise of advising the President to remove a judge, it had to make a preliminary determination on whether to make the recommendation or not with proceedings properly recorded and documented.
 
However, the Principal State Attorney Henry Oluka had argued that the JSC Act did not apply to judicial officers, such as Choudry and: that there was a lot missing in the law as to how the Commission should proceed in respect of such officer.

RELATED ARTICLES

Justice Choudry to be probed for misconduct

Handle justice Choudry complaints expeditiously

High Court Judge Choudry cries out

State asks High Court to ignore Judge Choudry's plea

The statements, comments, or opinions expressed through the use of New Vision Online are those of their respective authors, who are solely responsible for them, and do not necessarily represent the views held by the staff and management of New Vision Online.

New Vision Online reserves the right to moderate, publish or delete a post without warning or consultation with the author.Find out why we moderate comments. For any questions please contact digital@newvision.co.ug

  • mail
  • img
blog comments powered by Disqus
Also In This Section
Amuru district: 300 land disputes in one week
Over 300 land disputes have been recorded in the northern Uganda district of Amuru during a five-day free legal service week....
Judiciary introduces plea bargain sessions
The judiciary is in the process of introducing plea bargain practice directions in criminal justice mainly to decongest prisons....
EA media managers want reforms in journalism curriculum
Media managers in East Africa have asked journalism training institutions in the region to consider changing the curriculum from one which focuses on theories to a skill-based approach....
UPDF mourns Congolese general
The UPDF is mourning the death of their Congolese comrade, Maj. Gen. Ambamba Bahuma, who has been instrumental in fighting the Uganda rebel Allied Democratic Front (ADF) in North Kivu Province Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC)...
New test fast-tracks diagnosis for malaria
A new invention can cheaply and accurately diagnose malaria infection in just a few minutes using only a droplet of blood....
Man arrested for blocking enumeration exercise
A peasant farmer is in police custody in Lira for allegedly interrupting the ongoing national population and housing census....
Do you think banning the sale of single cigarette sticks will help regulate tobacco production?
yes
No
Can't Say
follow us
subscribe to our news letter