Chaotic Malawi election sparks legal battle
Publish Date: May 27, 2014
Chaotic Malawi election sparks legal battle
Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) candidate to the presidential elections Peter Mutharika (R) leaves his house flanked by his running mate Saulos Chilima, in Blantyre, on Sunday. PHOTO/AFP
  • mail
  • img

BLANTYRE - A week after Malawians went to the polls to elect a new president the result is still not known and fierce legal wrangling has raised the prospect of a protracted political crisis.

With at least 90 percent of the votes counted over the weekend, it was unclear if election watchdogs would release the results on Monday, and if the outcome would be recognised.

Amid reports of irregularities, the electoral commission, the country's incumbent president and opposition parties are embroiled in lawsuits and counter-suits over the count.

President Joyce Banda has said the vote was marred by "serious irregularities" and declared it "null and void," calling for a do-over within 90 days, which she will not take part in.

But it is not clear she has the constitutional power to make such a move and a court ordered the vote count to continue.

Malawi's electoral commission has admitted problems -- in some places the number of votes cast is greater than the number of voters -- but efforts to stage a recount have been blocked by a court order at the request of opposition leader Peter Mutharika.

On Friday with about a third of the votes counted, Mutharika had 42 percent of the vote, with Banda on 23 percent.

On Saturday Mutharika avoided claiming victory but said the "people have spoken and this was a free and credible election".

Banda's supporters believe the vote was far from fair, and fear the 74-year-old brother of late former president Bingu wa Mutharika may be attempting to steal power.

Peter Mutharika already faces treason charges for attempting to conceal his brother's death in office two years ago, as part of an alleged plot to stop Banda -- then vice-president -- from assuming power as directed by the constitution.

Amid the electoral confusion there are fears of political violence and the United Nations and the European Union have called for calm.

"The Secretary-General reiterates his call to the candidates and their supporters to respect the ongoing tallying process, follow existing legal procedures to resolve any electoral challenges or complaints," a spokesman for UN chief Ban Ki-moon said.

When voting was scheduled to begin last Tuesday the opening of some polling stations was delayed by as much as 10 hours because voting materials did not arrive, prompting isolated violence that saw at least one centre touched.

People cast their votes recently. PHOTO/AFP

But while the army was deployed to ensure tensions did not spill over, instances of violence have been isolated and some analysts believe the crisis has shown the power of Malawi's institutions.

"Despite the political twists and turns, the drama, and the general public uneasiness, I think Malawi has demonstrated, again, that it has strong, respected and impartial institutions," said Jeffrey Smith of the Washington-based Robert F. Kennedy Center for Justice and Human Rights.

Whatever the declared result it is likely that the lawyers will be further involved according to Dimpho Motsamai, an analyst at the Pretoria-based Institute of Security Studies.

Banda is "likely to take the ruling to the highest court... to clarify the validity of the law," she said.

Still Motsamai said the current period in Malawi represented a "worrisome period of uncertainty."

She also criticised Banda's administration for lack of preparedness to host the elections, saying logistic challenges should have been foreseen.

"Banda should have worked to strengthen the electoral body and its capacity to hold an election, that might be an indictment on her leadership."

The election imbroglio is unlikely to help Malawi's dire economic problems.

After taking office Banda oversaw the devaluation of the kwacha currency by 50 percent, the easing of foreign exchange restrictions, and the raising of fuel prices and cutting of subsidies.

That helped restore an IMF credit line, but the country remains overly dependent on agriculture and foreign aid to survive.

Foreign donors have already frozen some aid over the "Cashgate" scandal, which saw corrupt officials steel around $30 million dollars of state funds.


Also related to this story

Court stops Banda from halting polls

President declares Malawi election 'null and void'

Malawi vote counting system collapses

The statements, comments, or opinions expressed through the use of New Vision Online are those of their respective authors, who are solely responsible for them, and do not necessarily represent the views held by the staff and management of New Vision Online.

New Vision Online reserves the right to moderate, publish or delete a post without warning or consultation with the author.Find out why we moderate comments. For any questions please contact

  • mail
  • img
blog comments powered by Disqus
Also In This Section
Former PM Kabore elected president of Burkina Faso
Roch Marc Christian Kabore has won Burkina Faso's presidential election, official results showed, after a year of turmoil that saw the west African country's former leader deposed and the military try to seize power....
Putin snubs Erdogan in Paris as pilot
Russian President Vladimir Putin snubbed a meeting with Turkish counterpart Recep Tayyip Erdogan in France on Monday as the body of a pilot killed when Ankara downed one of Moscow's warplanes returned home...
Israeli parliamentarian resigns over sexual harassment claims
A rightwing Israeli politician has resigned from the country's parliament after a series of allegations of sexual harassment, the party announced on Monday....
Turkey to get cash, closer EU ties at migration summit
EU leaders will offer Turkey cash and a boost for its membership bid in exchange for its cooperation with the migrant crisis at a summit Sunday, but officials warned a final deal will involve "difficult" negotiations....
Dutch court blocks bid for Rwandan extraditions
A Dutch court on Friday blocked the extradition of two Rwandan men accused of involvement in the central African country''s 1994 genocide...
Burundi risks genocide, US envoy warns
BURUNDI is at risk of genocide, warns Thomas Perriello, US Special Envoy for the Great Lakes Region of Africa, days after President Barack Obama slapped sanctions...
Do you think Uganda is winning the fight against AIDS?
Can't Say
follow us
subscribe to our news letter