Judicial appointments should not be based on religion
Publish Date: Jan 22, 2014
  • mail
  • img

By Brian Kisomose

It is quite commendable to see to it that finally the judiciary and other arms of government have appointed six new judges.

 The judiciary is still ‘crippled’ due to lack of enough judicial officers but the recent appointments of judges is a credible step. This has, however, been criticised by some legislators who claim that the President is discriminating the Muslims.

In my opinion such an assertion is a misconception, unfounded and un authoritative argument aimed at fulfilling selfish interests of its authors, castigating hatred and segregation among citizens .The ‘desperate legislators ‘of all people should be in a better position to appreciate the fact that Uganda is a secular state and various religions have been respected because it is a creature of the supreme law of this land.

The bill of rights in the 1995 Constitution of the Republic of Uganda provides for equality of all persons and freedom from discrimination under Article 21.If one says that Muslims are not appointed then also other people from other religious sects will come out and demand for appointment not only in the judiciary but also in other government departments, ministries bodies and other institutions.

If the legislators claim that Muslims are only discriminated in the judiciary, does it imply that in other departments, arms of government and ministries they are not? If the answer is in affirmative then they cannot claim that they are discriminated, if the answer is no then the legislators are up to fulfilling their selfish interests as usual.

Muslims in Uganda are not a marginalised group. I am not a Muslim but I think equating them to such a category of people under Article 32(3) of the 1995 Constitution is an insult and quite demeaning. Literally marginalisation means to treat a person, group as insignificant or peripheral i.e. by removing such a religion from public space and reliably I do not think this has happened in Uganda.

It is a fallacy for one to say that the President is insensitive to the Muslim community. To me this does not in any way make sense at all but rather more or less like an analogy without formula. The Constitution is crystal clear when it comes to appointment of judicial officers.  Article 147 of the same provides for the functions of the judicial service commission and one of them among others is to recommend such officers for appointment. It is very clear that if the President appoints any judicial officer who has not been recommended by the judicial service commission and not approved by Parliament such an appointment will be null and void due to such illegalities and irregularities it will be more or less ‘defiling  the Constitution’.

My humble prayer to MPs Mariam Nalubega and Latif Ssebagala is to appreciate the law before driving the public astray .When one talks of Constitutional rights it does not simply mean relying on a few provisions of the law to the exclusion of others but to extensively interrelate with other legal provisions. Interlocking political and religious interests is a trend worth not taking because the two can never be reconciled.

Appointments of government officers and other employees in various departments should be based on one’s potential, credibility and competence among others but not religion, race, or tribe because religion and tribe are very sensitive issues that people take to be very personal. It may seem to be primafacie a simple concern as raised by the legislators but it can easily create hatred among masses and thus resulting into religious wars of which as a state we are not ready to shed blood sparked off by mere selfish allegations.

The appointment procedure in the judiciary as provided for in the Constitution is very transparent Whoever thinks qualifies to take on the responsibility of a judicial officer should be vigilant enough to respond to advertisements for such posts by applying for the same. I have never witnessed any advertisement in the media for judicial officers that restricts applicants’ basing on religious background.

The writer is from School of Law Makerere University


The statements, comments, or opinions expressed through the use of New Vision Online are those of their respective authors, who are solely responsible for them, and do not necessarily represent the views held by the staff and management of New Vision Online.

New Vision Online reserves the right to moderate, publish or delete a post without warning or consultation with the author.Find out why we moderate comments. For any questions please contact digital@newvision.co.ug

  • mail
  • img
blog comments powered by Disqus
Also In This Section
Why northern Uganda requires truth and reconciliation commission
One of the most powerful predictors of success in politics and public policy is the strength of political narratives. But do political narratives represent political reality...
Why is Einstein famous?
Part of the reason for Einstein’s fame is surely that his earliest, and best known, achievement – the 1905 special theory of relativity –seemed to have come out of the blue, without any prior achievement...
Culture and the best interests of the child
Ugandan and Canadian legislation, as well as international legal frameworks considering children, highlight the common law principle that the “best interests of the child” must be at the forefront of any decision...
AIDS under renewed attack
Appreciating the need for shared responsibility and African solidarity, the Private Sector members identified as critical the need to start locally producing Anti-Retroviral Drugs...
Why and how agriculture remains important to NRM
Recent innuendoes by Kizza Besigye, Amama Mbabazi, et al, that the NRM has overlooked agriculture are in essence hollow rhetoric under-pinned by repugnant political expediency...
Why we should enhance intercultural and religious dialogue
As humanity is now entering an era where discussions must go beyond the debates in the context of modernity, where religious and secularism are seen as opposites....
Do you think Uganda is winning the fight against AIDS?
Can't Say
follow us
subscribe to our news letter